11/23/13 71 W - + 7 - 7 Video - Tiller Versus Platform


Found via the FireNews.net Twitter feed, here's an interesting video that compares a tractor-drawn aerial ladder (or tiller) with a platform ladder. The two are compared in timed tests in deploying their aerial devices, and turning and manuevering their vehicles. The nine-minute video was posted by YouTube user Ted Collins.  There are a few nits worth picking, which we'll await as reader responses.
 




I don’t understand the point of this video. This is not an apples to apples comparison. Two totally different trucks with different key characteristics. I didn’t even watch the driving portion. There’s no need. A useful comparison would be how much quicker can an aerial be deployed vs. a large ground ladder but even then there would be difference in personal/crew preferences and situational differences favoring one over the other. I can say that the one this this vid proves is not to store a PPV fan in front of your aerial controls.
Bob - 11/23/13 - 23:36

This video shows a lot to, maybe, city/town council or a fire chief. It shows the argument of the benefits of a tiller vs. a bucket. Both has their advantages and disadvantages. I will take a tiller any day over a bucket because of what the video shows and past experiences. True statement about the PPV fan.
Shannon - 11/24/13 - 23:00

good point, Shannon. I wasn’t looking at it from that perspective, which does prove really enlightening to someone not familiar with performance characteristics….
Bob - 11/25/13 - 13:51

If the video also involved maneuverability through tight spaces and such, that would be extremely beneficial (if you were making a push for tiller pieces).
Silver - 11/25/13 - 18:52

Watch the whole video Silver.
Shannon - 11/25/13 - 22:21

Here’s a good tiller manueverability video from Seattle. http://youtu.be/QXcqFtPNLn8
Wants a tiller - 11/26/13 - 01:21

@Shannon, thanks! I saw the fan on the back bumper and punched out too early!
Silver - 11/26/13 - 01:34

The engineer operating the platform was obviously sandbagging. My assumption is the video was created by the department to compare what they have now to what they want/need to have as a replacement.
Rescue Ranger - 11/26/13 - 11:14

In regards to the Seattle video that shows the true difference between a tillerman and someone who sits in the rear to keep the trailer aligned with the tractor. Awesome driving. True talent. I know of some pump operators who couldn’t drive a pumper through those streets. Again, the difference between an engineer and a pump operator.
Rescue Ranger - 11/26/13 - 11:19

Well, as the resident lay person I was wondering why it took the guy so long to take that thing off the back of the ladder (didn’t realise it was a fan until after he got it off and put it on the ground)
Paul - 11/27/13 - 09:44



  
Remember personal info?

/ Textile

Comment moderation is enabled on this site. This means that your comment will not be visible on this site until it has been approved by an editor.

To prevent spam we require you to answer this silly question
 

  (Register your username / Log in)

Notify:
Hide email:

Small print: All html tags except <b> and <i> will be removed from your comment. You can make links by just typing the url or mail-address.